This is a series of posts for aspiring writers, established authors, and anyone inbetween. To take a look at what goes into a novel before, during and after it is written. Please feel free to comment if you have helpful advice that will contribute to making this post more beneficial to everyone out there. Or, post a question and I’ll try to find an answer!
You’ve got a plot, some of you have an outline. A character sketch, perhaps. But now, where do you start?
I wanted to post on hooking the reader because I’m becoming more and more convinced that, in this day of instant gratification and in-your-face opening lines or paragraphs in books, readers just aren’t willing to wait around for a writer to convince them they can tell a good story.
I’m guilty of this myself. If I start reading a book, laden with Stephen King doses of description and Austen proportions of building a scene, I have trouble making myself continue. (Unless, of course, it’s an Austen book, in which I’ll snuggle down and read it over and over again. You can’t touch the classics.) If I am not drawn into a book quickly, however, I have been known to set it down. Most times I return to it, but sometimes I don’t.
We readers want a good story and we want it now! That’s not to say all readers will dismiss a book solely based on opening chapters, but I’ve noticed more and more of late readers want a story over craft.
Samuel Goldwyn said, “What we want is a story that starts with an earthquake and builds to a climax.”
Precisely!
There is a great debate these days about what sells more books, story or craft? The craft might suggest to us we create our setting, introduce a place, the weather, our characters. That we establish a nice little background for the story before we actually jump into the story. But if we’re simply going for the story, readers expect a jump either right into the action or right into the mind of a wonderfully interesting character.
And the lack of this is the basis for rejections of many of my manuscripts in the past. I used to like to take the safe route. Build a foundation on which to start telling my story. You know, write all about the pretty trees and the fluff of clouds that billowed over a distant knoll. And on and on…But I truly believe what many readers want is what comes after all that building. I still struggle with it but I am learning.
If you have a strong voice, I believe you can start off your book however you like and still manage to draw a reader in. Not all new writers have that, however. I know I didn’t. And I would suggest to them to hook your reader as soon as possible. The first few pages of your novel might be what do or do not land you an agent or a publisher. And an agent does not have time to read four or five chapters to see if you’re eventually going to tell a good story. They’re going to want to know it almost right off the bat.
So hook your reader! Introduce a conflict or a strong opinionated MC who likes to make life difficult for those around him. Begin in the middle of an action scene or a humorous argument or debate. Or give a brief background for the story and then move on! You can add in details as you go.
So what do you think? Is good writing enough to keep you reading, or do you need to get drawn in quicker than a few chapters into the book? Will you put down a book you’re reading if it doesn’t interest you or will you keep going to see if it gets better?
The beginning is definitely something I'm going to have work on improving. I've changed it so many times...
ReplyDeleteI've recently decided to knock out the first four or five chapters because I felt the story didn't really start until the fifth chapter. Now I just have to figure out how to craft that beginning so that it's compelling enough for an agent to request for more.
I'm guilty of leaving many a book to collect dust because it didn't continue to hook me. I am definitely one of those entertainment craved modern readers who needs gratification throughout the entire book!!
ReplyDeleteTherefore as I write, I continually try to keep that in mind. But again, subjectivity comes into play. What might be exciting for me, might be completely boring for someone else. The trick is to find out what will draw in the majority of readers.
Great post, Cindy!
I need to be hooked, no question, but different things can hook me. In part, it depends on what I expect from the book. Certain stories I'm willing to allow to start more slowly, because the writer's sure voice reassures me the buildup will pay off. If the long, chapter worth of description and insipid dialog is clumsy and awkward to read, I'll probably put it down.
ReplyDeleteSo, a really strong plot hook can make me read in spite of clumsy writing, and excellent writing can keep me reading in spite of a slower plot. But if the writing and plot are both bad, that's trouble.
I like the thought of starting with an earthquake. I like to read books that begin that way as well. I need a reason not to put the book down. Great post Cindy!
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree that we want to be drawn in. Most people in America are very busy and to invest in a book is no fun unless we can tell it will payoff right away.
ReplyDeleteIf a book doesn't interest me, I don't read it. That's sad, because maybe I'm missing incredible stories, but it's just the way life is.
I agree with Tara too, that different things can hook me.
Dara, I have struggled with my beginnings as well. Many times I have had to ask other people how appealing the beginning is to see if it really does need work or I am just obsessing over it.
ReplyDeleteJody and Tara, you're totally right. Different things appeal to different people. I think that's why it's so important to research our individual genres to appeal to the most readers.
T. Anne, yeah, I need a reason not to put the book down as well. That's why I love reading books that are recommended by someone I trust because then I'll keep reading regardless of how interesting the first few chapters are.
That's so true, Jessica! Picking up a book and reading through to the end is an investment. And it is much too hard these days to invest in something that takes up time but we don't enjoy.
Once again, I go back to the Inciting Incident on this one. Many times it's a good place to start, especially for new writers. If that's what gets the story rolling, then most of the time it's pretty exciting. However, sometimes the Inciting Incident isn't exciting or needs too much setup, in which case I think starting with an event that branches from the Inciting Incident can also work well. I did this with my second novel.
ReplyDeleteI don't think it's a choice between story and craft. A truly great story and talented writer will combine the two. I'm still aiming for that, LOL.
Hey, thanks for stopping by my little blog.
ReplyDeleteI'm guilty of needing instant gratification myself.
*hangs head in shame*
I've passed on many a story because I was not immediately pulled in.
It's so true that, one must grab the reader in the first few pages and hold that interest. I've been working to revise my first chapter so that I get to the "good stuff" quicker. It's been rewritten so many times as I trim out setting and back-story to jump right into my opening fight scene. *sigh*
When it's newer fiction, I want to be pulled right in. When I'm on a classics kick, I am more than willing to wait to get really hooked.
ReplyDeleteGeneral tastes have changed over time. :)
I do need to fix my opening. Trim it really. Way too many pages before the story really starts.
I'm loving these posts, thanks for doing them Cindy!
I agree that, as writers, we need to start in the middle of the action. Then, having done that, we need to keep that action rolling. I know this because, as a reader, I've abandoned many books that failed to hold my interest. The way I look at it, if it's something I'd likely skim through as a reader, then I'm going to keep it short in my own writing.
ReplyDeletehi cindy....i've got to be drawn in really early...like, in the first couple of pages. now that i'm writing so much, if i'm not totally into a book by about pages 5-6...i'll put it down! thanks for visiting my blog!
ReplyDeleteLady Glamis, I am just going to have to link to your blog at the end of all of my posts, LOL. By the way, the book is good so far!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Meg, I am so glad you're enjoying them. I am learning a lot as well and seeing some flaws in my own writing that I need to work on.
Thanks for stopping by, Diane and Jeannie!
I totally can be hooked by the story idea or the writing. I'm likely to put something down if I don't like the writing off the bat. Although, I just finished a sci-fi book that I started off thinking that the writing was very weak, but the story was fantastic and I read it to the end and loved it.
ReplyDeleteThe hook can be a mysterious one, like setting a scene that asks a lot of questions.
ReplyDeleteThe hook doesn't have to be exciting or thrilling, it can simply make the reader curious.
I agree with Martin: "...it [the hook] can simply make the reader curious." Explosions are great when done well, but one can only stomach so many movies laden with cliche heroics and baseless destruction. Let's hear it for the subtle hook! What better way to catch a fish?
ReplyDeleteThe thing about classics is that they have already been vetted. You know that they will pay off in the long run if you look at them in the correct light.
ReplyDeleteThat is not guaranteed with a modern work, unless someone has gushed about it and you trust their judgment.
I am guilty of wanting a hook. I don't like to be shocked in the first line though. I like to be intrigued. I will read books with excellent writing and a good voice if they don't have a hook, but I love a good hook.
ReplyDeleteI heard an author say once that you should never join a scene as it starts, you should always jump into it alright going so your reader has to keep up. Never be afraid to challenge your reader. :)
I'm a patient reader, but I do love writing that grabs me in the first few pages.
ReplyDeleteIMHO, the genre affects my tolerance level. A suspense book better contain plenty of action from the get-go, while tenderness and yearning are essential to romance. I've found literary novels require a slower pace to savor a delicious phrase or get the full impact of setting.
That's my two cents for today. Great post. I'm linking to it for my Friday Round-Up. :)
Blessings,
Susan
It depends on the book, but I have so little time for reading that lately I am impatient with a book if it doesn't get moving fast enough.
ReplyDeleteThat being said, I recently read The Book Thief and thought it began slow, but all the good reviews I read on blogs and the amazing writing, kept me going and in the end I was so glad that I did!